Swing Check Valve VS. Spring Check Valves. What are the ...

Check valves are fixtures that let fluid flow in only one direction. Backflow prevention is the most prominent feature of a check valve. Spring and Swing check valves are crucial check valve types. They prevent backflows in systems using different mechanisms as per their structure. Here is the difference between the swing and spring check valves.

Link to BSTV

Swing Check Valve:

The swing check valve allows or stops the flow of fluids by swinging a flapper. This mechanical device relies on the swinging motion of a flap or a hinged disc. The flapper turns away from the seat to allow the liquid, giving fluids enough space to escape. For the valve to close, the flapper turns back towards the seat and blocks backflow.

The situation creates automatic valve closure on decreasing pressure in the system. The valve&#;s swinging operation enables it to bear large flow capacity easily. At the same time, due to swing motion, these valves cannot perform well in horizontal or upward vertical conditions.

Bronze swing check valve drawing and spare parts

Specifications:

Product NameBrass Swing Check Valve Size1/2 &#; 2MaterialLead-free brassFinishingSand-blastedThreadBSP, NPTWorking Pressure200 PsiTemperature-15°C to 115°CMediumWater or Non-corrosive liquids.Brass swing check valve specs

Swing Check Valves: Pros and Cons.
Swing Check valves have the following set of advantages and disadvantages.
Pros of Swing Check Valves:
&#;Moderate Flow Capacity:
Swing check valves are suitable for applications having moderate flow rates. This property also makes them adhere to variable flow in many systems.
&#;Minimum Clogging:
Swing check valves have the least risk of clogging among all check valves. This is because the swinging motion dislodges the debris and prevents blockage.
&#;Less Pressure Drop:
These check valves are best for applications where minimizing pressure loss is essential. They can perform far better than other check valves in such requirements.
&#;Low Cost:
Another aspiring advantage of swing check valves is their low cost. They give reliable performance within a very economical budget.
&#;Large Flow Capacity:
Spring check valves are excellent products to manage large flow capacities.
Cons of Spring Check Valves:
&#;Slow Closure:
Spring check valves do not offer quick closure like some check valves. It can lead to water hammering in conditions where immediate valve closure is necessary.
&#;Limited Reverse Flow Tolerance:
In case of high reverse flow pressure, swing check valves may not provide an effective seal. The disc gets limited at high pressure and can lead to leaks.
&#;Slamming:
As swing check valves are limited to high flow, they can be prone to slamming at high flow. Yet, this effect can be reduced by using a damping device.

Applications of Swing Check Valve:

Swing check valve

A few applications of swing check valves are as follows.

Municipal System:

Swing check valves prevent flood in the sewage system. They also block the backflow of gases and liquids through various channels in municipal systems. They also manage and avoid contaminations from entering into clean water.

Fire Protection System:

Swing check valves are applicable in water sprinklers in fire protection systems. They ensure no backflow occurs as a fire-fighting equipment blockage can cause potential damages.

Marine Environment:

Swing check valves mark the effective working of ships by managing backflows. They prevent seawater and fuel from backflowing.

Industrial Processes:

Swing check valves are widespread in almost every industrial process. They block reverse chemical and other fluids flow in refineries and chemical plants.

Petrochemicals:

These valves are efficient in controlling various fluids in the petrochemical industry. Their primary function is to prevent mixing different chemicals and make processes go smoothly.

Brass swing check valve

Spring Check Valve:

Spring check valves operate via a spring mechanism. They contain large stoppers in hollow bodies actuated by spring pressure. When fluid flows forward at high pressure, it causes the spring to open. The situation arises when the force of fluid overcomes spring pressure. Thus, the path is open, and liquid can move across.

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit Industrial Swing Check Valve.

Specifications:

Product NameWater Spring Check Valve  Size1/2 -2, 1/2 -4MaterialH583, CW617N, CW602NFinishingSand-blastedThreadsBSP, NPTWorking Pressure200 PsiSpringStainless SteelTemperature-10°C TO 100°CSpring check valve specifications

Spring Check Valve: Pros and Cons.
Here is a list of advantages and disadvantages of the Spring check valve.
Pros of Spring Check Valve:
&#;High Flow Rates:
Spring check valves can undertake high flow rates as they can handle large volumes.
&#;Quick Closure:
The spring in the valve offers efficient and quick closure in case of backflow. This property saves from hydraulic issues like water hammering.
&#;Flow Orientation:
Spring check valves are not limited to only vertical or horizontal flow. Instead, unlike swing check valves, they can manage fluid in any direction. They can also handle upward and downward flow because gravity does not influence the spring&#;s working.
&#;Versatile:
Spring check valves are one of the most versatile among all check valves. Their design can be adaptable for multiple industries and suits many applications.
&#;Positive Sealing:
Spring provides the most reliable positive sealing in case of reverse flow. They also keep a check when the direction of backflow changes.

Cons of Spring Check Valve:
&#;Spring Fatigue:
Spring in check valve can be prone to fatigue over time. It can result in lesser sealing capacity and poor efficiency of the valve.
&#;Limited to Low-Flow:
Spring check valves have a design that suits high flow rates. Thus, they are limited to low-flow applications and may need to improve in these conditions.
&#;Higher Maintenance:
The spring in the check valve takes more maintenance to keep working. They usually need more care and inspections than swing check valves.

Applications of Spring Check Valve:
Spring check valves can be applicable in the following industries.
Irrigation System:
In the agriculture field, spring check valves ensure a unidirectional water flow. It saves irrigation lines from contaminating due to backflow.

brass spring check valve with brass pin

Aerospace:

Spring check valves are applicable in the aerospace industry to ensure the system&#;s safety. They prevent the backflow of hydraulic fluids and fuel.

Automotive Industry:

In automobiles, spring check valves make brake operation workable. They block the backflow of brake fluid.

Residential Plumbing:

Residential plumbing systems use spring check valves on a large scale. They let fluid flow in one direction only in water supply lines and pumps, etc.

Hydraulic Systems:

In different hydraulic systems, spring check valves manage hydraulic fluids for the safe working of the system.

inline spring loaded check valve

General Differences: Swing Check Valve vs. Spring Check Valve.

Here are some general differences between the swing and spring check valves.

PropertySwing Check ValveSpring Check ValveDesignCompact DesignBulkier design due to springClosure MechanismSwing Disc or a FlapDisc pushed by SpringClosure SpeedSlow closure speedQuick closure speedPressure DropLower pressure dropModerate pressure dropRange of Flow RateSuitable for low to moderate rateSuitable for high-flow rateResistance to CloggingLess prone to CloggingLess prone to CloggingApplicationsBest for low or moderate-flow rate applications.Versatile and can apply in multiple applications.Differences in specifications of check valves

The Bottom Line:

Swing and spring check valves offer many features, making them a top choice for non-return valves. While selecting between spring check valves vs. swing check valves, consider application demands a top priority. Plumberstar offers many reliable check valves curated to meet industry standards. Mark your requirements and get the most suitable check valve for your system.

Hmmm interesting re no longer code

Mine was set up 20 yrs ago. I don't think it ever worked well because one pipe was never warm and the other was slightly warm

I was considering adding a Recirc pump but didn't want to spend the money and never really had an issue waiting 30 secs for the water to get warm upstairs

I also was worried about combining the recirc pump with the Caleffi tank mixing valve because the guy installed the return line into the cold water inlet. I've seen that doing this with a pumped hot water recirc can just let the valve drift upwards to the max temp of the tank which is dangerous of course and also negates the reason for having the mixing valve in the first place. I guess he could repipe the recirc into the bottom of the tank and just have the cold water feed go into the mixing valve.

I guess for now I can just ask him to install the swing check on a horizontal section of that recirc line and see whether that can let us open the ball valves on those lines yet stop the backwards cold water flow. I am on his dime right now since he forgot to do this. Or would y'all advise me spending more money to have him add a recirc pump and repipe the recirc line into the tank drain at the bottom? If I never minded the short wait for the past 20 yrs are there other reasons I should spend this money? (Bacteria argument for example)

 

For more Flanged Ball Valveinformation, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.