Choosing Between Diaphragm & Piston Pumps: Which is Best for Dry Running?

Choosing Between Diaphragm & Piston Pumps: Which is Best for Dry Running?

When it comes to selecting the right pump for dry running applications, the two most commonly used types are the diaphragm pump and the piston pump. Both of these pumps have their pros and cons; so, in this article, we aim to provide an analysis of these two types of pumps, to help you make an informed decision.

Diaphragm Pumps.

Diaphragm pumps are commonly used in applications that require high flow rates, self-priming capabilities, and compatibility with abrasive and viscous fluids. The diaphragm pump is designed to use a flexible diaphragm to create suction, which is similar to the action of a straw when sucking liquid.

The diaphragm pump is best suited for dry running applications as it involves minimal contact between parts, which minimizes wear and tear. Additionally, diaphragm pumps are also suitable for pumping corrosive substances, which require compatibility with non-reactive materials.

However, when it comes to a diaphragm pump's disadvantages, it is prone to membrane rupture and limits the flow rate compared to the piston pump. This pump type is less energy-efficient than the piston pump and is more challenging to maintain and repair.

Piston Pumps.

Piston pumps operate by using a piston, which moves back and forth in a cylinder to create pressure variations that are used for pumping fluids. Piston pumps are commonly used in high-pressure applications and are highly efficient due to its continuous operations and higher flow rate relative to the diaphragm pump.

Piston pumps are also ideal for dry running applications since they can operate without any fluids or lubrication. There is also no chance of membrane rupture compared to diaphragm pumps, and the piston pump's hydraulic seals can tolerate any form of fluid pressure variation.

The disadvantage of using a piston pump is that it requires frequent maintenance, and it can clog over time, thus limiting its ability to handle abrasive or viscous fluids.

The Decision.

Which pump is better for dry running applications, you ask? The answer is that it depends on what the needs of the application are. For applications that require high flow rates and self-priming capabilities, choosing a diaphragm pump may be the better choice. For applications that require no fluid and lubrication, a piston pump may be the best choice.

Final Thoughts.

Ultimately, the right pump selection starts with a detailed understanding of a given application's requirements. To make a final decision on which pump type is suitable, make sure you consider factors like initial costs, maintenance costs, efficiency requirements, and material compatibility.

If you have any questions or concerns about choosing the right pump for your application or would like to be connected with a reputable supplier, please contact us. We are always happy to help.

For more dry running diaphragm pumps, piston pump working principle, piston pump operating principleinformation, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.